Ziegenfuss BL, Launay MM, Green NR, Maharaj JC, Stalin KA, Barlow G, Erbulut DU, Whitehouse SL, Vijaysegaran P, Pivonka P, Cutbush K, Gupta A
The Latarjet coracoid transfer procedure reliably stabilizes the glenohumeral joint for shoulder instability. However, complications such as graft osteolysis, nonunion and fracture continue to affect patient clinical outcomes. The double-screw (SS) construct is regarded as the gold standard method of fixation. SS constructs are associated with graft osteolysis. More recently, a double-button technique (BB) has been suggested to minimize graft-related complications. However, BB constructs are associated with fibrous nonunion. To mitigate this risk, a single screw combined with a single button (SB) construct has been proposed. It is thought that this technique incorporates the strength of the SS construct and allows micromotion superiorly to mitigate stress-shielding graft osteolysis.
The primary aim of this study was to compare the failure load of SS, BB, and SB constructs under a standardized biomechanical loading protocol. The secondary aim was to characterize the displacement of each construct throughout testing.
Computed tomography scans of 20 matched-pair cadaveric scapulae were performed. Specimens were harvested and dissected free of soft tissue. SS and BB techniques were randomly assigned to specimens for matched-pair comparison with SB trials. A patient-specific instrument (PSI)-guided Latarjet procedure was performed on each scapula. Specimens were tested using a uniaxial mechanical testing device under cyclic loading (100 cycles, 1 Hz, 200 N/s) followed by a load-to-failure protocol (0.5 mm/s). Construct failure was defined by graft fracture, screw avulsion, and/or graft displacement of more than 5 mm.
Forty scapulae from 20 fresh frozen cadavers with a mean age of 69.3 years underwent testing. On average, SS constructs failed at 537.8 N (SD 296.8), whereas BB constructs failed at 135.1 N (SD 71.4). SB constructs required a significantly greater load to fail compared with BB constructs (283.5 N, SD 162.8, P = .039). Additionally, SS (1.9 mm, IQR 0.87) had a significantly lower maximum total graft displacement during the cyclic loading protocol compared with SB (3.8 mm, IQR 2.4, P = .007) and BB (7.4 mm, IQR 3.1, P < .001) constructs.
These findings support the potential of the SB fixation technique as a viable alternative to SS and BB constructs. Clinically, the SB technique could reduce the incidence of loading-related graft complications seen in the first 3 months of BB Latarjet cases. The study is limited to time-specific results and does not account for bone union or osteolysis.